The impact of standards-based report cards on reading achievement in the third grade

Date of Award

Spring 2014




Doctor of Education


Counseling, Foundations & Leadership


School districts across the nation are transitioning away from traditional A-F letter grade report cards in favor of standards-based report cards (SBRC). Previous studies have indicated that many parents were confused by SBRC. The purpose of this study was to determine if a difference exists between the reading achievement of third-grade students using traditional A-F letter grade report cards and those students using SBRC. Pre-existing CRCT data of the pass/fail percentage of third graders from five school districts and 118 schools in 2009 and 2010, the year prior to and the year of implementation of SBRC, were analyzed. A chi square test indicated that no statistically significant difference existed between report card type and student reading achievement among third grade students. Districts may want to reconsider the time and expense involved in adopting a report card that so many parents find difficult to understand.

This document is currently not available here.